+1

Wow... rough move from Ubuntu to PCLinuxOS!

Linux

Seeing as it has been a few months since I tried out a new distro, I got a wild hair today and decided to give PCLinuxOS (Gnome version) a shot.  The way that I keep my drives partitioned - specifically keeping my /home directory as a separate partition- swapping distros is usually a pretty painless endeavor and I can be back up and running within an our or so, with all my old apps in place and with all my preferences still in tact.

As I booted to the PCLinux Live CD, everything seemed to be business as usual.  The only notable point was that I thought that PCLinux has a nice default theme and icon set in the Gnome version of the distro.

So without too much hesitation, I went ahead and began the install process.  After choosing the appropriate keyboard and timezone settings, I was presented with the choice of how I would like my partitions setup, which by default uses the entire physical disk.  By selecting the "do it yourself" mode, I expected to be able to choose my smaller /dev/sda2 partition as my / mount point, format it for the OS, and leave my /dev/sda3 alone mounting it has /home. 

I entered what appeared to be a nice little partition configuration tool (Disk Drake I think?), which appeared to be exactly what I was needed.  I then selected the /dev/sda2 partition as the place I wanted my / mount point, and chose /dev/sda3 as my /home mount point.  When I chose the option to format my / mount point, I got a an error message that said that the partion could not be formatted.  Considering that my plan was to wipe it out anyway, I went ahead and removed that partition, and re-added it using that utility.   As I tried to move forward, I got a message that indicated that I needed to reboot, restart the installation process, then choose "Use existing partitions".  Simple enough right?  

I then rebooted to the live CD and entered the installation again.  This time I was presented with a new option.  "Choose the partitions you would like to format" and it only listed my larger /dev/sda3 partition with a checkbox next to it, with no mention of my /dev/sda2.  I found this a bit interesting, and after carefully removing the checkbox I moved forward. As I entered the next step I went to a screen "Copying files...".... wait... huh?  To where? 

Apparently it now considered my /dev/sda3  (which I intended to be /home) as the only drive.  I cancelled the process and opened the terminal.  After browsing to that directory, I found new /usr and /boot directories in that directory, which confirmed my suspicions. 

Things then began moving downhill and picking up speed....

I opened the partitioning tool GParted and was suprised to see that not only did my 15GB /dev/sda2 not exist anymore but that /dev/sda3 was now a 145GB partion of unallocated space.   NOT GOOD, considering that about 110GB of it is *very* allocated with data that I didn't intend on losing.

Even with all the steps I have taken since, I have been unable to mount /dev/sda2.  I even popped in Damn Small Linux to attempt some quick surgery and even it was unable to save me.   I then tried an Ubuntu live CD and it didn't recogize anything on /dev/sda at all.  At some point during this process I noticed that I was getting "bad magic number" and "corrupted superblock" type messages in relation to that device.

After putting the PCLinuxOS live CD back in, I was a bit relieved to see that it auto-mounted /dev/sda3 as /media/disk, and that I could at least access the files that were once safe and sound in my /home directory. 

So.... here I sit waiting for GBs upon GBs of data to upload via FTP to various servers so that I can wipe the enter friggin thing out and start over.  Tomorrow I get the fun of retrieving it all and piecing my laptop world back together....   <sigh/>

More to come....

alynch said:
 
So, where is the update on the distro installation?

;)

 
posted 181 days ago
View Replies (1) || Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
.: HIDE REPLIES :.
Andrei said:
 
Traitor to our cause! 8-)

I tried PCLOS, but it is weak compared to Ubuntu. Although it is number one DistroWatch, this distro does not look polished or reliable.

Aghh, do not spend your life playing with distributions, just enjoy life..
 
posted 181 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
ruel24 said:
 
Type your message here!
 
posted 181 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
johan.budh said:
 
Well... Not to state the obvious, but I wouldn't install a development release of any other distro (or OS) without doing a backup first.
 
posted 181 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
67GTA said:
 
I had the exact same problem, only I lost my Ubuntu /home partition. I don't care for the PCLinuxOS partitioner. I installed it on a friends PC, and just used gparted to set up the partitions for the PCLinuxOS install. I didn't have to deal with the partitioner then. I just told the installer where to write. If you choose the default install, it will erase everything and set up a separate partition for almost every directory (/home, /root, /var, /dev, etc...) and gparted will not be able to read the disk afterwards.
 
posted 181 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
ruel24 said:
 
Type your message here!
 
posted 180 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
ruel24 said:
 
The problem you experienced was a bug that somehow found it's way into the final release of PCLinuxOS 2007 final. It wasn't in any of the test releases previously, and was also a but present in the originating package from Mandriva. Unfortunately, it wasn't discovered in time, but only effected some machines, which I believe used certain SATA controllers. This same bug was a problem on my machine, and I was forced to revert to PCLinuxOS 2007 TR4 to get it installed.

PCLinuxOS 2008 is about to be released, and shouldn't contain this bug.

I personally have been a user that jumped around quite a bit from distro to distro, and used most of the bigger, and a few smaller distros, including Ubuntu and Kubuntu. PCLinuxOS is so good, it put an end to my distro hopping. I've been a happy camper with this distro for almost 4 releases now. It's that good.

As far as the comment about it being a development release, it is not. PCLinuxOS 2007 was released quite some time ago, and is getting ready to be replaced by PCLinuxOS 2008. A minimal install disk, complete with a minimal KDE, is availabe, called PCLinuxOS 2008 MiniMe. The full release final is due any time and I strongly encourage others to try it. The Gnome version is a community remaster, and should follow shortly thereafter.
 
posted 180 days ago
View Replies (1) || Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
.: HIDE REPLIES :.
BnB said:
 
I agree that with 'ruel24' this bug does not affect *all* the users, and I have to say that I also have been a victim of this bug while installing PCLinuxOS 2007.

The fact that I am disappointed with PCLiunxOS is NOT because of this bug, but due to that fact that this bug is still present in the PCLinuxOS Gnome version (which is a pretty recent release).

Tch.. tch.. PCLinuxOS, 7 months, and this bug still exists.

People are losing their important data because of this. Please go ahead and fix this...
 
posted 179 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
Reuben said:
 
If you enjoy playing with new distros, but don't want all the nerviousness of installing on your primary work machine, I recommend using VMware Player/Server. Both are free to use and will run Linux seamlessly on your existing system.

If you go the VMware player route, there are websites that will create the guest OS profiles for you so you can install the system without having to hand-code the config file.

Personnaly, if you are doing a lot of work w/in a VM guest, it is worth the $190 to get VMware workstation. I cannot tell you how many times having my primary dev environment installed on a VM has saved my bacon and still allowed me to satisfy my curiousity with software.
 
posted 91 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
 
I have always used VMWare Server for that type of thing. In fact, a dirty little secret is that this blogging network, InstantSpot, used to run in a VM on an Ubuntu server. Lately, however, I have been using VirtualBox. It really sweet virtualization software, and it's in the Ubuntu repos!

It also has a very sweet built-in ability to do seamless mode with guest operating systems.
 
posted 90 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 

Search

Dave at work...